A/B testing in email marketing to improve results

When we do email marketing, even small details can make a big difference: a subject line, a button color or even the placement of a CTA can be the reason for a successful campaign and a failed one. But how do we know which is the best choice? Part of the answer can be found in A/B testing in email marketing, a technique that allows us to make decisions based on real data and not on assumptions.

Which subject line will capture more opens? Which button color will lead to more clicks? These questions, which may seem subjective, are essential when you email your subscribers and the results don’t convince you. With A/B testing, you can greatly improve your metrics while gathering information about your audience’s preferences.

In this article, we explore what A/B testing in email marketing is, how to run it, and how to interpret its results to maximize the impact of your campaigns. If you’re looking to improve your email marketing strategies, this is the perfect place to start.

Introduction to A/B testing in email marketing

A/B testing, also known as split testing, is a methodology that allows you to compare two versions of the same element to determine which one generates better results. In email marketing, this involves sending two variations of an email to specific segments of your subscriber list and analyzing which one has superior performance based on metrics such as open rate, clicks, or conversions.

Why is A/B testing important in email marketing?

A/B testing takes the guesswork out of your email marketing strategy. Instead of basing decisions on what we “think” will work, we can rely on hard data. According to a report by Campaign Monitor, companies that regularly conduct A/B testing achieve a 37% increase in their click-through rate compared to those that don’t.

In addition, A/B testing allows us to:

• Optimize every element of the mailing: such as subject lines, CTAs, images, and layouts.
• Identify audience preferences: understand what type of messages resonate most with your subscribers.
• Reduce the risk of errors: test on a small segment before implementing large-scale changes.

Elements you can test in an email

There are many elements in an email that can be A/B tested, including:

1. Subject line: the first impression counts, and an attractive subject line can significantly increase the open rate.
2. Mail content: from tone to text length.
3. Design and formatting: images, colors, typography, and layout.
4. CTA: text, color, size, and location of the button.
5. Sending time: Is it better to send a mailing in the morning, at noon, or in the afternoon?
6. Segmentation: test different approaches based on demographic or behavioral groups.

Each of these elements has the potential to impact metrics, so it is important to test them strategically and in isolation.

***

A/B testing takes the guesswork out of your email marketing strategy

***

Types of A/B testing in email marketing

A/B testing is one of the most widely used tools to optimize email marketing campaigns, but not all tests are the same. Understanding the different types of tests available will allow you to choose the right methodology according to the objective of your campaign and the metrics you want to improve. Here, we analyze the main types of tests used in email marketing:

1. Standard A/B tests

Classic A/B testing consists of comparing two versions of the same email (version A and version B) to measure which one performs better. This method is ideal for making specific adjustments and evaluating the impact of a single change.

Key features:

• Test a single element at a time: for example, two different subject lines, two button colors, or two mail layouts.
• Audience splitting: the subscriber list is split into two groups of similar and representative size.
• Direct results: data shows which version generated better key metrics, such as open rates, clicks, or conversions.

Advantages:

• Simplicity and ease of implementation.
• Clear and easy-to-interpret results.
• Ideal for identifying specific adjustments that generate impact.

Disadvantages:

• Limited to only one change per test.
• Does not provide insights on complex combinations of elements.

Example:

An e-commerce store performs an A/B test on the subject lines:

• Version A: “Discover our exclusive offers”.
• Version B: “Save up to 50% today”.

Analysis reveals that version B generates 20% more opens, indicating that subject lines with concrete numbers are more effective for your audience.

2. Multivariate testing

Multivariate testing goes a step further by allowing the comparison of multiple variations of various elements within a single mailing. This approach evaluates how different changes interact with each other and which combination generates the best results.

Main features:

• Complex testing: multiple combinations of changes are tested simultaneously.
• Interactions between elements: identify which combination of elements (subject line, layout, CTA) works best.
• Requires more data: needs a large sample size to ensure statistically significant results.

Advantages:

• Provides deeper insights into how different changes interact.
• Optimizes multiple elements in a single test.

Disadvantages:

• More complex to implement and analyze.
• Less effective with small subscriber lists.

Example:

A SaaS wants to test design and text combinations for a conversion mailer:

• Subject line: “Get more productivity” vs. “Increase your results today.”
• CTA: Red button vs. blue button.
• Design: Cover image vs. minimalist design.

With three elements and two variations each, eight possible combinations are generated. The version with “Increase your results today”, a red button, and a cover image generates 35% more clicks, standing out as the best option.

3. Multistage testing

Multi-stage tests are used when we want to test different elements in consecutive campaign phases. This approach allows iterative adjustments based on the results of each stage, progressively optimizing the performance of the mailings.

Key features:

• Continuous optimization: results from one test inform decisions for the next stage.
• Use in automated flows: ideal for email marketing campaigns with multiple mailings, such as welcome series, lead nurturing, or reactivation.
• Less statistical approach: relies more on practical iterations than on complex mathematical analysis.

Advantages:

• Allows dynamic adjustments over time.
• Ideal for long flows or automation.

Disadvantages:

• Requires more time to implement.
• Results may be less definitive if variables are not adequately controlled.

Example:

In a welcome campaign, a B2B company tests two versions of the first mailer to measure which one generates more clicks to a resource page. Once the best version is identified, they adjust the second email in the flow to maximize time on the page. This iterative approach improves each stage of the funnel.

Which type of test to choose?

The choice between standard, multivariate, and multistage A/B testing depends on your goals, resources, and subscriber list size. Here are some recommendations:

• Use standard A/B testing: when you want to make a specific change and measure its impact simply.
• Use multivariate testing: if you want to optimize several elements simultaneously and have a large database.
• Use multistage testing: in automated campaigns or when optimizing entire mail streams.

How to run A/B tests in email marketing

Although A/B testing may seem like a simple process, its execution requires meticulous planning to obtain positive results. Here is a step-by-step guide to perform them in your email marketing campaigns.

1. Define a clear objective

Before starting an A/B test, it is essential to be clear about what you want to improve. A clear objective directs your efforts and makes it easier to measure results.

For example:

• Do you want to increase your open rate? Then try different subject lines.
• Looking for more clicks on your mailing? Experiment with different CTA formats or design.
• Do you want to increase conversions? Test variations in content or offers.

2. Select a single element to test

For the results of an A/B test to be reliable, it is important to test only one element at a time. This allows you to identify exactly which change generated the improvement. For example:

• If you test two different subject lines, keep the rest of the email identical.
• If you change the color of a button, make sure the content does not vary between versions.

This strategy, known as “variable isolation”, avoids confusion in the interpretation of results.

3. Divide your audience into equal groups

An A/B test requires dividing your subscriber list into two homogeneous and representative groups. This ensures that the differences in results are due to the element tested and not to variations in the characteristics of the groups.

For example, if you have 10,000 subscribers:

• Send version A to 5,000 subscribers.
• Send version B to the other 5,000.

Many email marketing tools, such as Mailchimp, HubSpot and Klaviyo, allow you to make this division automatically.

4. Define an adequate sample size

To obtain statistically significant results, it is important to work with an adequate sample size. If the sample is too small, the results may not be representative. Use sample size calculators to determine how many subscribers you need to include in your test.

5. Monitor and measure results

Define the metrics you will evaluate according to your objective. For example:

• For the subject line: open rate.
• For the content or CTA: click-through rate.
• For the offer: conversion rate.

Let the test run for a defined period, usually between 3 and 7 days, to collect enough data.

6. Analyze and apply the learnings

Once the test has concluded, analyze the results and determine which version was most effective. Then apply the learnings to future campaigns.

Segmentation in A/B testing in email marketing

Segmentation is a helpful technique in A/B testing because it ensures that the results obtained are representative and relevant. By dividing your audience into homogeneous and well-defined groups, you can accurately measure the impact of the changes made, ensuring that the differences observed are due only to the variations tested and not to other factors. This is especially important in email marketing campaigns, where subscriber characteristics and behaviors can drastically influence results.

Let’s see how to apply segmentation effectively in A/B testing and what benefits it brings.

1. Why segment in A/B testing?

As we have said, segmenting your audience to perform A/B tests in email marketing improves the accuracy of the results, but also offers several benefits such as:

• More accurate results: ensures that the groups tested are comparable, and that differences are not due to inherent biases in the audience.
• Deeper insights: allows you to analyze how different segments respond to tested variations, helping you to tailor specific strategies for each group.
• Efficient decision-making: quickly identify which changes work best for specific audiences, optimizing future campaigns.

2. How to segment for A/B testing in email marketing

Segmentation for A/B testing should be based on relevant criteria for the test and on significant audience characteristics. Here are the steps for effective segmentation:

Step 1: Choose relevant criteria to segment

Define which subscriber characteristics are most important for the element you are testing. Some common criteria include:

• Demographics: age, gender, geographic location.
• Behavior: frequency of interaction with mailings, purchase history, resource usage.
• Preferences: interests selected during registration or inferred from previous interactions.
• Funnel stage: new subscribers, qualified prospects, active customers or inactive users.

Step 2: ensure the homogeneity of the groups.

Once the audience has been segmented, divide each segment into equal subgroups for A/B testing. This ensures that any differences observed between the tested versions are due to the change introduced and not to pre-existing characteristics of the group.

Step 3: Use segmentation tools

Take advantage of email marketing platforms that offer dynamic segmentation, such as Mailchimp, Klaviyo, or HubSpot. These tools can automatically divide subscribers into relevant segments and assign them to versions A and B.

Example: a SaaS company wants to test two versions of a subject line to improve the open rate. They divide their audience into:

• Segment 1: users who opened at least one email in the last 30 days.
• Segment 2: users who have not interacted in the last 60 days.

Both segments are divided into subgroups to test versions A and B, ensuring comparable results tailored to each level of engagement.

3. Advanced segmentation in A/B testing

If you have a robust database, you can implement advanced segmentation strategies to obtain deeper insights:

• Psychographic segmentation: in addition to demographic or behavioral characteristics, consider factors such as values, motivations, and lifestyles of your subscribers. This can be especially useful in campaigns that seek to generate an emotional connection with the audience.

• Device segmentation: Test specific variations for users who open emails on mobile devices versus desktop. This can be key if you’re testing layouts, images, or CTAs that might behave differently by device.

• Segmenting by purchase history: divide subscribers according to their purchase behavior, such as frequent customers, new buyers, or users who have not yet made a purchase.

***

Run A/B tests to collect sufficient data over a defined period, usually between 3 and 7 days.

***

Using A/B testing tools in email marketing.

A/B testing is essential to optimize email marketing campaigns, and the success of these tests depends largely on the tools we use. Nowadays, email marketing platforms, in addition to their basic A/B testing functionalities, also incorporate advanced capabilities such as dynamic segmentation, automation, and real-time analysis. Let’s take a look at how to choose and use tools to implement A/B testing in email marketing.

1. Essential features of an A/B testing tool

When selecting an email marketing platform for A/B testing, it is important to ensure that it has the following key features:

• Ability to perform specific tests: the tool should allow you to test different elements of the mailing, such as:

• Subject lines.
• Content (text, images, structure).
• CTAs (buttons, colors, locations).
• Delivery schedules.
• Audience segments.

• Automated audience splitting: a good tool automatically splits your subscriber list into representative groups to ensure statistically significant results.

• Integration with metrics: the platform should measure and report metrics such as open rates, clicks, and conversions. In addition, it should automatically calculate which version is the winner.

• Automation to apply results: once the best version has been identified, the tool should allow sending it to the rest of the audience without manual intervention.

• Advanced analysis: Functions such as segmentation of results by device, geographic location, or previous behavior help to obtain deeper insights.

2. Popular A/B testing tools

There are multiple tools designed for email marketing, each with specific functionality for performing A/B testing. Below, we explore the most popular ones:

Mailchimp: one of the most widely used platforms for email marketing and A/B testing, especially for small and medium-sized businesses.

Notable features:

• A/B testing for subject lines, content, images, and more.
• Automatic segmentation to divide the audience into homogeneous groups.
• Clear analytics with key metrics such as open rates, clicks, and conversions.

Advantages:

• Intuitive and easy-to-use interface.
• Ideal for businesses starting with A/B testing.
• Multivariate testing functionality in advanced plans.

HubSpot: a comprehensive marketing and CRM platform, ideal for companies looking for advanced personalization and analytics capabilities.

Notable features:

• A/B and multivariate testing integrated with CRM.
• Advanced conversion tracking and funnel-specific metrics.
• Segmentation based on behavioral data and demographics.

Advantages:

• Allows linking A/B testing results to the customer journey.
• Excellent for lead nurturing strategies and complex campaigns.

Klaviyo: designed especially for e-commerce, with advanced functionalities for A/B testing.

Outstanding features:

• A/B testing for individual mailings and automated flows.
• Segmentation based on shopping and browsing behavior.
• Integration with platforms such as Shopify and WooCommerce.

Advantages:

• Ideal for personalizing messages based on behavioral data.
• It offers specific insights into customer buying patterns and habits.

ActiveCampaign: combines email marketing capabilities with advanced automation, making it ideal for companies looking to optimize every touchpoint.

Notable features:

• A/B testing for individual mailings and automated flows.
• Real-time dynamic segmentation.
• Advanced personalization based on CRM data.

Advantages:

• Compatible with complex campaigns and customized automation.
• Provides detailed analysis of test results.

3. How to choose the right tool

Choosing an A/B testing tool will depend on factors such as the size of your subscriber list, your marketing goals, and your budget. Here are some tips for selecting the best option:

Evaluate your needs.

• If you need to perform basic testing (such as subject lines or button colors), platforms like Mailchimp may be sufficient.
• For more advanced strategies involving automation and personalization, consider tools like HubSpot or ActiveCampaign.

Consider integration with your current systems: Make sure the tool can integrate with your CRM, CMS, or e-commerce platform to make the most of available data.

Think about long-term growth: decide on a tool that can scale with your needs. While a basic platform may be adequate now, a more advanced one may be necessary as your database grows.

Analyze the cost-benefit: evaluate the price based on the functionalities it offers. Some tools like Klaviyo may have a higher cost, but its integration with e-commerce may justify the investment if you sell products online.

Results of A/B testing in email marketing

The results of A/B tests can provide insights into the behavior and preferences of your audience. Here are some examples of results you can get and how to interpret them.

1. Improved open rate: If you test different subject lines and one of them generates 15% more opens, you can conclude that that version resonates better with your audience. This could indicate that your subscribers prefer shorter lines, questions or a more informal tone.

Increased click-through rate: A test with different CTAs could show that a red button generates 20% more clicks than a blue one. This suggests that certain colors or texts have a stronger psychological impact on your audience.

3. Increase in conversions: Testing different offers can reveal which incentives are more effective. For example, a 20% discount might outperform free shipping, depending on your customers’ priorities.
4. Design insights: A clean, minimalist design can generate better results than an email cluttered with images and text. A/B testing will help you find the ideal balance between aesthetics and functionality.

Conclusions

A/B testing in email marketing is an indispensable tool for any specialist, which allows us to optimize each element of our campaigns and gives us valuable insights into what matters to our audience. By performing these tests constantly, we can stop relying on assumptions and make decisions based on concrete data.

To achieve good results with this exercise, emphasis must be placed on planning: define a clear objective, test only one element at a time, and analyze the results rigorously. As Avinash Kaushik said in Web Analytics 2.0, “Without data, you’re just another person with an opinion.” A/B testing transforms our opinions into evidence-based strategies, taking our email marketing campaigns to the next level.

Ready to experiment? With A/B testing, every campaign is a reason to learn, grow, and connect with our audience.